Nintendo's biggest blunder: sticking to cartridge games for too long (poll results)

Posted Nov 24, 2005 at 12:00AM by QJ Staff Listed in: News, Off Topic Tags:
Ó


3060000000047187

Joystiq asked their readers to weigh in on what they believed Nintendo’s biggest blunder of the last 20 years to be. Here are the results, out of 5,814 votes cast:

  • 1,703 votes (29%): sticking to the cartridge-based format for too long
  • 1,507 votes (26%): focusing on the younger gamer demographic
  • 947 votes (16%): gimmicky products (ROB, Virtua Boy, etc)
  • 932 votes (16%): draconian 3rd-party development contracts
  • 584 votes (10%): Late rollout of the N64 and GameCube (vs PlayStation and PS2)
  • 141 votes (2%): Other (write in)

Of the “other” votes, the top write-in had to do with the botched Sony relationship that ultimately lead to the creation of the PlayStation console and to Nintendo’s fall from the top spot.

Do any of these mistakes have bearing on the console war now underway? Some say that Microsoft and Nintendo are repeating the “cartridge” format mistake by not including support for Blu-Ray or HD-DVD disks with their new systems, but the difference between cartridges and DVDs was an is far greater (both in terms of storage capacity, cost, and techology) than the difference between regular DVDs and DVDs with higher storage capacity.

 
 
 

Comments [refresh]

by sabernet - 1999-11-29 19:00



Darconian licensing: $ony PSP

Focusing on younger demographic(or rather lack-of younger demo.): Micro$oft Xbox(any gen)

gimmicky: Nintendo(but it's actually working for them this time:) the gimmicks are ctually fun).



by - 1999-11-29 19:00



Im gonna have to go with the botched sony relationship. Also, for the issue on cartridges or discs, cartridges wernt up against DVDs, they were up against CDs. Nintendo made the same mistake again with the GCNs minidiscs, but they had enough room for it not to be too great an issue. But I realy think high capacity discs will be a problem for Xbox, they will NEED them. NRev i dont think will though, i see them making more simple games, that are just plain fun, like Eyetoy and singstar games (except, rather than a camera or a microphone, it uses an even more inovative approach.)



Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Add QJ.NET
Add to My Yahoo!
Google Reader Subscribe with Bloglines
Add  to your Kinja digest Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Subscribe with Pluck RSS reader Add 'www.qj.net' to Newsburst from CNET News.com
Subscribe with SearchFox RSS del.icio.us www.qj.net
Add to Technorati Favorite! Add to My AOL
furl! it Stumble for Treehugger!