Quick Jump Daily Digest

Thank you for your interest in the Quick Jump Daily Digest. Get notified of all new content on QJ in our free Daily Digest. To subscribe, enter your email address below and click the subscribe button.


Email Address:


Email will come from "donotreply@caputomedia.com". Please whitelist this email address.

Cancel and Return to page

Movie buffs reveal next-gen console midterm grades

Posted Jul 6, 2007 at 3:59PM EST by QJ Staff

Listed in: PS3, Wii, Xbox 360 Tags: Christmas, Elite, HDMI, Microsoft, Nintendo, Sony
Ó

The movie industry has had few and far between when dealing with issues of the game industry. It is the biggest and most mature sector in the entertainment front since music. While most bickering over the next-gen console wars happened in-house, the movie buffs were unmoved by the fans' enthusiasm for their favorite consoles and the companies backing them.

Movie buffs reveal next-gen console midterm grades - Image 1


Unforgiving critics themselves, entertainment media mogul Entertainment Weekly took a step back to review their impressions of today's next-generation consoles: the Nintendo Wii, Microsoft Xbox 360, and Sony PlayStation 3. And it appears that they were no more excited for any of the consoles than they were the first time around.

The Xbox 360 hasn't changed in grade at all, with their midterm impressions not changing from their first encounter with the console. They leave the grade at A- in anticipation of a price cut this year, although they do agree that the Wii may take the throne soon. They note that a strong game lineup and a good online network will keep the Xbox 360 as "the console to beat," although it must be fair to point out that it just celebrated its first anniversary while the other two are still starting out.

The Nintendo Wii, according to Entertainment Weekly, is the probably the biggest disappointment to them - dropping from a high B+ to a low B- - after a drought of really good games had the console giving off the first signs of "Wii-nnuii." The lackluster lineup of titles has outweighed the console's growing sales numbers and the lack of truly online games tip the balance against the Wii's favor. Even one of Nintendo's big three titles is enough to bring their Wii-nthusiasm back, but as they say, "no one's likely to care."

The PlayStation 3 is a technological marvel to the movie critics, especially because they are fans of the high-definition movie experience. The HDMI and the Blu-Ray DVD experience is one thing to behold in the CELL-powered console, something that even the Xbox 360 Elite lacked without a packaged HD-DVD add-on.

The game lineup for the PlayStation 3 isn't any more varied than the Wii, and Sony's lack of a "bold executive decision" to slash prices left the reviewers no choice other than to dip the grade. But just in case Sony does drop the price just once before Christmas, they're temporarily notching the score at a B- from their first impression of a B.



This story sucks? This story rocks!
Vote Now!    This story ROCKS! (0) This story SUCKS!! (0)




Become a Member of QJ.Net!

If you want your comments to go live without waiting for moderation, you need to be logged in. Being logged in has its benefits:
  • Logged in members do not wait for their comments to be approved.
  • Logged in members can sign up for nightly updates.
  • Logged in members can create Profiles to be seen by other users.
So why wait? Create an account or login now! It's easy, quick, and free.

To get started, use the LOGIN boxes, or the REGISTER link at the top right!

Comments 


 
# come onGuest 2007-07-06 17:16
Now thats just bullcrap, you know the PS3 is the smartest one there, the Xbox360 is a frikkin pothead

Reply
 

 
# gamesGuest 2007-07-06 17:31
are always going to change the outcome, i mean, if halo 3 and MGS4 switched exclusiveness (halo3 as ps3 exclusive and MGS4 as 360 exclusive) i promise you! that many would ether b!itch and wine and start many crapy online petitions, or simply except it and buy the console...

Reply
 

 
# low B!Guest 2007-07-06 18:49
What the F_uck! A low B! Thats bullsh-it! Wii should at least be an A-

Reply
 

 
# PS3 won first Place.Guest 2007-07-06 19:00
halo is not made by microsoft just bought bungie. original it was exclusive for apple owners, cheap bastards M$. 30% failure rate for 360, while ps3 zero to hero no doom. "360 is Games for Windows duhh no need to buy xbox." gear of war on pc, lol true. no need pay to play online xbox. bigger games won't have room to complete 1 disc except for ps3. worth the price to ps3 now price cut. 360 elite is so lame its the 5th broken xbox, haha. xbox does take up more space than ps3 literally.

watch this proves everthing and the music in ps3

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VrdE11_iYK8&eurl=http%3A%2F%2Fwww%2Edestructoid%2Ecom%2Fps3%2Dfanboy%2Dvideo%2Dproves%2Dthat%2D99%2D9%2Dof%2Dyoutube%2Dusers%2Dare%2Dstupid%2Das%2Dhell%2D33631%2Ephtml

Reply
 

 
# what kind of movie buffs were these? ones that don't watch movies?Guest 2007-07-06 19:37
PS3 should have been the top easily, best HiDef and DVD player by far. The Wii can't play DVDs. The 360 has dreadful DVD playback and is a handicapped HDDVD player, which can't support all the available video and audio formats on HDDVD, and has problems playing all the discs even

Reply
 

 
# oooGuest 2007-07-06 19:46
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v+VrdE11_iY

K8+eurl+http%3A%2F%2Fwww%2Edestructoid

%2Ecom%2Fps3%2Dfanboy%2Dvideo%2D

proves%2Dthat%2D99%2D9%2Dof%2D

youtube%2Dusers%2Dare%2Dstupid%2Das

%2Dhell%2D33631%2Ephtml

Reply
 

 
# PS3 a B?!Guest 2007-07-06 21:27
Ps3 a B?!

Wtf?!

Those movie industry jerks know nothing about concoles..I own all three and I favor the PS3 over everything else..Xbox is great...except all it has are shooter titles...

Wii is fine but very lacking in Games [All I'm using my Wii for is Virtual Console titles...I mean I own 6 games on the Wii..only 6!]

PS3 has it all...Bluray movies [they kick Azz!] Awesome Graphics and games that are fun to play..even though I will admit the Sixaxis motion sensors are a little meh...that's just me..

Still, I give the PS3 an A+ for what it's worth.

The Wii an A and the Xbox 360 an A-...remember that's just me so don't go hating me Xbox fan boys - remember I own one of each system so technically I'm one of you too!

Reply
 

 
# I hate when they assumeGuest 2007-07-06 21:27
Me and half the people that have PS3s didnt buy it because of blu-ray, yet every1 make it seem that way... Its like saying if HD-DVD was built in the 360 people say its the star feature and you'll be like huh? I bought my PS3 for MGS4, killzone 2, Heavenly sword, Warhawk, lair, every other thing coming out plus now Home.

Reply
 

 
# Youtube videoGuest 2007-07-06 21:32
Stfu with da links to PS3 or 360 sucks videos...

Reply
 

 
# Why are people angry...??Guest 2007-07-06 22:09
why do individuals in here assume every human beign is mature and intelligent



there are people buying a system with a 33% failure rate percentage for christ sake and they are happy that should it ever break at any moment,they will have to part from it for 4 days until it returns to them.



so you buy your newest game today,start playing it online with excitment a little more than the usual,and suddenly the system fails and you have to part from it and your newly purchased game for 4 days if not more



why would anyone want to buy such a continous headache ??



the Catastrophy is that there are people who are defending a company that rushed a defected product into the market.



Entertainment weekly are doing there job to advertize for microsoft and the 360,dont blame them...they are paid for it



blame the idiots who go out to buy a system that can break at any moment,with 1 billion dollar reserved for repairing just imagine how many 360,s have broken and how many will Break !!!



this also suugest that the problem is concerned with multiple hardware issues [as moore said byhimself],incl uding the GPU,CPU and motherboard



meaning that MS found its self unable to solve the problem since it consist the entire architicture of the 360 system and the GPU "Xenos" which is an untested prototype not tested for long-term reliability thus it overheats causing the meltdown and complete system failure



but i guess it doesnt matter.....people will always side with their religion



even if they were foolish enough not to realize that they never chose that religion.....they were just born with it ,forced with it,they never had a choice



at least when buying a multi-media system,you have a choice.....

Reply
 

 
# iiiiiGuest 2007-07-06 22:26
(((( Cut the price to $500, and if that doesn't move units, prepare to cut the price some more. ))) you idiots its not even winter and could not wait after e3 big day. ps3 is already getting the price cut. wrong day to submit this grading article. listen to egm mag to tell you this year thought about it. rumble is already going to come back.

Reply
 

 
# yoGuest 2007-07-06 22:29
360 is already bad for having 30% failure rate that is like BS grading for a- console. maybe they should try running happy horrible vista

Reply
 

 
# The_RegulatorChuck Norris 2007-07-06 23:21
I agree 100%

Reply
 

 
# wrongAoxomamoxoA 2007-07-07 00:25
A low B is completly unfair, it should be more like an average C.

Reply
 

 
# ...Guest 2007-07-07 00:56
Dude you do not know that you tottally contradicted your self there.

Reply
 

 
# its kinda lame...chickdigger802 2007-07-07 02:27
that they didn't mention about games at all when they talked about ps3, and criticized wii for it >.> No one gives a crap if something can play dvds on a console... Go get a 20 dollar dvd player to do that...

Reply
 

 
# ?Guest 2007-07-07 06:00
I own more shooters on the ps3 then xbox360 you dumbass fanboy.

Reply
 

 
# hmmGuest 2007-07-07 06:03
I love the ps3. But it doesn't have many games right now.





my 360 has only broken once.



And I won't sell it...because I have games that I love.



you fanboy need to just calm down.



The ps3 will get better games soon.



But no reason to hate on the 360.



Sure it might have a high failure rate but so did the ps2.

Reply
 

 
# why the hell did you bring up PS2Guest 2007-07-07 07:50
PS2 has nothing to do with the failure rate of the PS3...they used cheap quality materials in order to make the PS2 at a more reasonable price at 299, and believe me, seven years ago, the inflation is not as bad...and PS3 is 599 dollars, partly because of its robust entertainment features and partly because of its high quality materials, in fact, PS3 is probably the highest quality console out right now, then Wii, than 360, which is worst.

Reply
 

 
# ?!Guest 2007-07-07 08:00
cok sucker...

Reply
 

 
# another dumb article posted by QJGuest 2007-07-07 09:11
it was the editors not the actual movie industry that rated the systems. I have the issue, and the thing is lame. Here's what the real movie buffs had to say about the PS3.



http://www.blu-ray.com/news/?id=273



Almost unanimously voted for by both forum and staff members, Sony's PlayStation 3 (PS3) became the Blu-ray player to own soon after its release last November. Since then, the popular game machine has received numerous updates, all accessible through the machine's built-in Internet ports, to provide increased stability and features. Most recently, Sony added DVD upconversion to the list of features, and overnight the PS3 became one of the top DVD players on the market as well.



Like most players, there were some initial issues, but the flexible nature of the PS3 hardware meant quick fixes for Blu-ray enthusiasts. BD-Java updates were also distributed quickly, usually before the title utilizing those new features ever hit store shelves. The inclusion of Dolby TrueHD and upgrade to 24p video output means that the console is equally applicable to both the casual movie watcher and dedicated home theater enthusiast.



The strength of the player comes from its awesome processing power. This means that upcoming advances like DTS Master Audio and BD-Java Picture-in-Picture (PIP) are not totally out of the question (though no promises to their addition have been made). Still, the future looks very bright for the PS3 as a Blu-ray player. With an expected price drop for the holiday season, this will not only be the best Blu-ray player available, but also remain one of the cheapest.

Reply
 

 
# Don...Shatterdome 2007-07-07 09:53
They were not rating the systems based on movie playback, but it was movie buffs giving their view of how the systems are doing, as GAMES systems.



This is why they add online features and games lineup to their equation....not just straight movie playback.



Because then the PS3 would have to go first then 360 and they shouldn't even mention wii since it really doesn't play movies...even DVDs...



Why do they mention Blu-ray you ask ? Well, many, many, many people see it as the only reason to get a PS3....as does entertainment weekly....without it their score would have been a C or C+ max.

Reply
 

 
# .Guest 2007-07-07 10:01
F.U.C.K you shaterdome. Nerd

Reply
 

 
# yepMorbidly 2007-07-07 11:42
good call

Reply
 

 
# HmmmmGuest 2007-07-07 17:03
So, are you, someone who doesn't know the difference between there and their, claiming to be intelligent? Interesting



BTW, a simple Google search for "xbox 360 design flaw" will reveal why the 360 defect rate is so high, and it's not because "the GPU "Xenos" which is an untested prototype not tested for long-term reliability thus it overheats causing the meltdown and complete system failure"



Try putting at least a little effort into your comments, especially if you're going to try to make it sound like you know what you're talking about when you really don't, something you fail at miserably

Reply
 

 
# Re: shatterdomeGuest 2007-07-07 21:40
Read what I said... I hate when people assume is what I said. People are dumbas5s thats why they say that 5hit. Cause I know my PS3 is gonna be put to use with all the games that are coming. (And the ones that just came)

Reply
 

 
# Re: qwGuest 2007-07-07 21:46
Actually thats part of da problem... If it keeps overheating it will eventually die out.

Reply
 

 
# The PS3 has gamesGuest 2007-07-07 21:52
Resistance, R6V, Motorstorm n others. but mostly da 360 has what? Gears n GRAW 2 or somthing... Well lets base it on exclusives mainly.

See what im saying...?

Reply
 

Add comment

Security code
Refresh


Welcome to QJ.Net!

If you want your comments to go live without waiting for moderation, you need to be logged in. Being logged in has its benefits:
  • Logged in members do not wait for their comments to be approved.
  • Logged in members can create Profiles to be seen by other users.
So why wait? Create an account or login now! It's easy, quick, and free.

To get started, use the LOGIN boxes, or the REGISTER link below!



Want to learn more about the team who brings you the QJ news?

Read about them now!


RSS Feeds Follow us on Twitter Find us on Facebook
Login:

HOT FLASH GAMES

Turbo Rally

Bakugan ATV Offroad

Duty Hill 2

Pork Must Arrive TD

Mechwarrior 3D

Ice Racing 3D