Quick Jump Daily Digest

Thank you for your interest in the Quick Jump Daily Digest. Get notified of all new content on QJ in our free Daily Digest. To subscribe, enter your email address below and click the subscribe button.


Email Address:


Email will come from "donotreply@caputomedia.com". Please whitelist this email address.

Cancel and Return to page

Killzone 2 E3 2005/E3 2007 comparison: pre-rendered against real-time

Posted Jul 15, 2007 at 5:21PM EST by QJ Staff

Listed in: PS3 Tags: e3, industry news, Sony
Ó



This story sucks? This story rocks!
Vote Now!    This story ROCKS! (0) This story SUCKS!! (0)




Become a Member of QJ.Net!

If you want your comments to go live without waiting for moderation, you need to be logged in. Being logged in has its benefits:
  • Logged in members do not wait for their comments to be approved.
  • Logged in members can sign up for nightly updates.
  • Logged in members can create Profiles to be seen by other users.
So why wait? Create an account or login now! It's easy, quick, and free.

To get started, use the LOGIN boxes, or the REGISTER link at the top right!

Comments 


 
# ...Guest 2007-07-15 18:58
FIRST!!!!! Not as good, but still looks great

Reply
 

 
# asdfGuest 2007-07-15 19:15
To be honest I see not much of a difference only the volumetric fire and debris.

Reply
 

 
# do knowGuest 2007-07-15 19:30
this is in pre pre-alfa build so the game will look even better than this

Reply
 

 
# game betterGuest 2007-07-15 19:47
Guys

agree or not Trailers are encoded and kinda compressed Games look much better one example is Warhawk itsself. Killzone2 will much much better when played realtime on our screens..



what do u guys say.. ?

Reply
 

 
# i have this gameGuest 2007-07-15 19:53
its pretty good

Reply
 

 
# pieGuest 2007-07-15 20:02
ITS BETTER IN THE SECOND ONE!

Reply
 

 
# NiceGuest 2007-07-15 22:02
I just downloaded this from PSN and it looks even better in HD. If it does improve by the time it comes out, it may look just like the 05 showing.

Reply
 

 
# Maybe, but not much better...Guest 2007-07-15 22:37
It's been in developement for years now (with a HUGE team), E3 was the first realtime showing. I'm not putting it down (it looks great), but the game engine seems mostly complete now, therefore most of the time between now and launch will probably be work on the game content (they're going to want to make it as big as possible to justify Blu-ray and say why it couldn't be done on the 360).



We'll see.

Reply
 

 
# AgreeGuest 2007-07-15 23:19
I also downloaded it from PSN, and it looked much better then what I saw from Gametrailers.



BUT!!! What they say in this movie about volumtric fire. In the realtime movie it is deffinitly not volumetric fire but just flat particle sprites!. You can even see that de Z-ordering is not right.



Also with the explosion, its just not volumetric smoke. Really, its not what we've seen in the techdemo of the PS3 with the nice explosion at the gasstation. Too bad. But still the game looks pretty nice!. Go Holland (H)

Reply
 

 
# pwnedGuest 2007-07-15 23:23
Watch how blood comes from enemys when they get shot! PWNED!

Reply
 

 
# very impresive..Guest 2007-07-16 00:25
sure the detail and textures arent the same quality and fire and explosion effects could use some refining but that would be crititizing a of sea gold over some dust in its surface



remember this is an alpha build....and the game is slated to use propietary lighting techniques [developed by Sony itself] and FSAA,and many previewers suggested that the real-time show-case demo was running at 1080P



i also share IGN belief that the game is running at 1080P....according to their analysis the game was so sharp even on the large screen [and they suggests that the game was actualy running on 1080P]..incredible



if that is true....then the game would define the Bar for console graphics,no other game puts 1080P,FSAA and such special lighting effects and intentsity at the same time,maybe some of the elements but not all together on a "Console"



this isnt about whats not done before...this about how much is done in the same time,Killzone 2 just puts so much together that i havent seen in any Console game before [i am not refering to PC games...since PC,s have infinite system resources]



Kudos for Sony and Guerilla games for such a Gargantuan effort....they single-handedly lifted all the negative aura on the PS3...and completely took the carpet from Halo3



E3 has passed but nearly no one talks about the Halo3 single player showing...with the exception of few fans,Killzone managed to ruin MS showing [not that the Re-hashed Halo 2 engine would,ve impressed regardless]



i will be curious to see the Console UT3.....until now only the PC version has been shown,but i would like to see a console version in-game trailer

Reply
 

 
# your really are retardedGuest 2007-07-16 01:08
wtf is wrong with you Mister common douche, Gears of was is trash compared to this get a grip you *****ing idiot , it'll take you guys 4 DVD9 disk just to fit this High res beast, and its in 1080P you need the elite 360 for that LOLZ

Reply
 

 
# Mission Accomplished...Guest 2007-07-16 01:23
I think that its mission accomplished.... in some aspects the game looked better than the pre rendered, - for instance, the blood, and the body movements when characters get shot, I mean that was beyond what we saw in the pre rendered trailer.

Reply
 

 
# ...Guest 2007-07-16 01:30
Fire, smoke and debris are disapointing.

Reply
 

 
# I don't agreeGuest 2007-07-16 01:41
It looks great, but texture quality, polygon levels, animation, particle effects (volumetric smoke for instance), are all below the pre-rendered trailer.



It looks great, but it doesn't match the 2005 trailer.

Reply
 

 
# fireGuest 2007-07-16 01:45
i think that some improvements could be made to the fire effects but overall this looks incredible and i can't wait to get this and say ***** you 360!!! LOL

Reply
 

 
# It's a shame..Guest 2007-07-16 01:46
..when gamers respond like you have, since it makes you no better than mister common sense. He keeps posting like that because it's so easy to get to guys like you. :|



Gears of War is certainly not trash compared to any game, and where have they confirmed that Killzone 2 is in 1080p?

Reply
 

 
# wordGuest 2007-07-16 01:48
the only thing i see wrong with kz 2 are the terrible textures on the peoples clothes which im pretty sure their goign to clean up sicne its really obvious

Reply
 

 
# wow idiotGuest 2007-07-16 01:51
um did you see the REAL gameplay trailer? goto gametrailers.com and they have a video of someone playing the game

Reply
 

 
# 360 can do 1080pGuest 2007-07-16 01:53
any 360 can do 1080p so dont say anything dumb without doing research you make sony fans look bad. i lvoe sony myself just letting you know. The real difference in 1080p that sony has is that its hdmi port is 1.3 which the 360's is like 1.1 or 1.2

Reply
 

 
# Really?Guest 2007-07-16 02:00
"E3 has passed but nearly no one talks about the Halo3 single player showing..."



From what I'm seeing on the websites, Killzone isn't getting muh more converage than Halo 3, in fact, I would have expected far more since it was the first time the game had been shown running in realtime. Even here on QJ, the Killzone threads have hardly set these forums on fire, which is surprising given all the hype.



Not a single webite have ignored Halo 3 in favour of Killzone, and all those who have seen Halo 3 single player have come away with great impressions of the game they saw. And this is the game 360 owner will be playing in a few months, whereas Killzone will be next year.



You seem to see what you want to see. :|

Reply
 

 
# Damn close!Guest 2007-07-16 02:45
It's pretty close to the trailer. I'd definitely agree that the explosions and even the fire need work, but 6-8+ months is a long time. Even if the engine is pretty much done and now they're just adding content it's pretty much guaranteed that they're still going to polish it visually a hell of a lot.



I think what people who aren't interesed in killzone or don't want to like it don't pick up on the subtleties of it. The way the bullet impacts realistically move the helghast as they are shot. The ever present and blowing atmosphere and effects like the sparks which billow away from some explosions in the wind. The way one of the dying helghast crawls a few feet and the blood flows from his and leaves a pool trailing behind him.



Don't get me wrong. Halo 3's definitely one at the top of my list too. "Re-hashed Halo 2 engine" Gimme a Break! IT'S HALO. THE THINGS IN THE GAME ARE SUPPOSED TO LOOK SIMILAR. It's beautiful! And they've still hardly shown anything. I think that Killzone is already pushing the envelope a bit more technologically , but I'll bet there will be scenes in halo 3 that the killzone engine couldn't do, or certainly couldn't do better.



Anyway, both look great. Littlebigplanet is going to be one of the most amazing games ever. I think it's safe to say it already IS the most amazing game ever. Really.

Reply
 

 
# It makes a change...Guest 2007-07-16 03:00
...to see a long post which was actually worth reading.



Great post. :)

Reply
 

 
# i dont wish to bring your excitement down..Guest 2007-07-16 03:39
" but I'll bet there will be scenes in halo 3 that the killzone engine couldn't do, or certainly couldn't do better."



dont bet.......it will not happen,not with the Aging renderware engine that Halo3 is using



i will respect your feelings,but that shall not be,not unless they completely throw that "Last-Gen" engine,re-write it or better make a propietary one like Sony always does



the DVD drive will prove a severe problem for streaming,its slow....Mass effect developers already mentioned in IGN,s [Hand-on of mass effect] that the game has many pop-ups,slow down and lag issues....when asking the development team,they attributed these to the DVD drive [meaning the game has to run on the core sku,they cant make the HDD a requiremnt it has to stream from the slow DVD]



the PS3 has no such problems,it has a standrad HDD...this is how they manage to make a "2GB" level in Killzone 2 all-streaming in game...they use both the blu-ray and the HDD at the same time



Microsoft desicion not to incluse an HDD in the core will prove troublesome and lethal....2 games in hand-on preview has shown problems,GTA4 [check IGN preview] and Mass effect,Both have pop-ups and lags [due to slow-stream loading]



bottom-line,Killzone has the Engine and Hardware advantage,and if there is anything am sure about that is that "Re-hashed" Halo2 renderware engine will never touch some medi-core 360 games let aside Killzone 2



mircales are not coincidences or wishful thinking....they are forged and made,Guerrila games worked hard to acheive this,a rehashed engine will never touch it



apologies again....

Reply
 

 
# Killzone CoverageGuest 2007-07-16 03:47
Trust me Killzone 2 is getting more coverage than Halo 3. Go to www.n4g.com and u will see that Killzone 2 is the hotter game.

Reply
 

 
# didnt set it on fire ??Guest 2007-07-16 04:00
"I would have expected far more since it was the first time the game had been shown running in realtime. Even here on QJ, the Killzone threads have hardly set these forums on fire, which is surprising given all the hype."



The Killzone 2 thread has over 129 comments



what you want it to reach 300 comments to set the site on fire,Halo 3 single player showcase doesnt even exist on the most comment or most jumped section in Qj



heck...even halo wars gathered more attention than Halo3 thats hardly great coverage or interest from gamers



ofcourse nothing beats the Xbox 360 failure rate news in the most jumped section XD

Reply
 

 
# Oh pleaseGuest 2007-07-16 04:04
"dont bet.......it will not happen,not with the Aging renderware engine that Halo3 is using"



Bungie are not using Renderware, they have ALWAYS developed their OWN in house game engines for Halo, and Halo 3 is no different. So get your facts right.



The fact that you do not know this means I can already dismiss your clueless post without going any further.



It's a proprietry engine written by Bungie, so instead of getting your facts from gamers on forums, try getting them from reliable sources, such as company websites and interviews with developers. That way perhaps you'll learn something.

Reply
 

 
# Obviously you haven't been here longGuest 2007-07-16 04:12
"The Killzone 2 thread has over 129 comments"



With all due respect, that's nothing special.



"what you want it to reach 300 comments to set the site on fire,Halo 3 single player showcase doesnt even exist on the most comment or most jumped section in Qj"



Neither does MGS4! Oh do you think gamers are not interested in MGS4 now?



As gamers, all we've seen is a new trailer for MGS4 and Halo 3, and for H3 single player, we've only seen a few impressive screenshots, but not the demo shown to reporters at E3, hence there's not much to get excited about either game compared to what we'd seen before. Now if there was gameplay footage of MGS4 and Halo 3 single player online, then there would have been much to talk about.

Reply
 

 
# As if to prove my pointGuest 2007-07-16 04:19
"the DVD drive will prove a severe problem for streaming,its slow...."



Too slow? The DVD drive in the 360 is FASTER (and yes, much noisier) than the Blu-ray drive in the PS3 (on average about 35% faster, but up to 80% faster on the outer tracks), so again, you show you don't know what you're talking about. :|



The advantage of Blu-ray is not speed, it's capacity, and it's quieter because the data is packed much more densely on the disk compared to DVD, meaning it doesn't have to by spun as fast.

Reply
 

 
# Worse..Guest 2007-07-16 04:25
"It's a proprietry engine written by Bungie, so instead of getting your facts from gamers on forums, try getting them from reliable sources"



Link ?....



if this is a propietary engine made in-house thats one of a hell of a let-down engine



i know Halo2 used Renderware,Halo 3 looks the same with a little more sharper texture,if that was an in-game engine they might as well use Renderware since there is no real difference



Microsoft cant even help bungie develop an in-game engine to compete against the aging renderware



i,l need to confirm this.....it could make my day

Reply
 

 
# Here's what was actually said on IGN.Guest 2007-07-16 04:30
"BioWare's Greg Zeschuk explained to IGN where the game is in its development cycle and why the little bumps are still in the game. The content, he explained, is finished. However, since the game is entirely streaming, where you put the content on the DVD itself can effect how it runs. Placing everything in a place where it can easily load whenever it is needed is a tricky task and one the team is currently working on."



so, not quite what you're saying now is it. Also, the HDD is not ruled out because of the core 360, since Bethesda used the HDD in the 360 version of Oblivion to improve load times. All it meant was that gamers with the core 360 didn't benefit from HDD caching, but other 360 gamers did.

Reply
 

 
# bla blaXman 2007-07-16 04:30
you sony fans can talk all the tech stuff you want!! the fact is that the game play doest look like the trailer!! in fact gear of wor looks better!! as for holo 3, it looks better already and its not even the full game, they just shown a demo that will most likelie look better by lunch in septembre!! so all the tech talk dont matter because the proof is in what we see!!

Reply
 

 
# what a slow-brainGuest 2007-07-16 04:36
"Too slow? The DVD drive in the 360 is FASTER (and yes, much noisier) than the Blu-ray drive in the PS3 (on average about 35% faster, but up to 80% faster on the outer tracks), so again, you show you don't know what you're talking about. :|"



Jesus..



go read what i typed...the advantage is the standard HDD in the PS3 not the drive [My god...i have to explain everything]



the HDD can stream at 35.5MB/Sec [for a normal SATA],combined with Blu-ray speed stream at about 9MB/sec [PS3 can use both,as ID Tech 5 will have the abiltity to stream from both]



the 360 DVD can stream 16MB/sec at best and will fall down to 10MB/sec and lower in inner layers [its inconsistent speed and slow]



rather than wasting my-time explaining,go read the IGN on Mass effect/GTA4 Lag,and pop-ups



what a Headache...

Reply
 

 
# adadadaGuest 2007-07-16 04:47
"Neither does MGS4! Oh do you think gamers are not interested in MGS4 now?"



actualy MGS4 is in the most jumped and most comented section

Reply
 

 
# The enthasist is on you to prove itGuest 2007-07-16 04:54
"Link ?...."



You're the one who made the claim, therefore it's for you to provide a link which says Halo uses Renderware. The fact is, this is an internet myth, because it has never been stated by either Bungie or Criterion, the creators of Renderware. Hence lists of Renderware powered games over the years have NEVER included the Halo series, i.e.



http://www.answers.com/topic/renderware



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RenderWare



In interviews I've read from Bungie since before the first Halo was released, they've spoken about their in-house game engine, not the use of a third party game engine, modified or not.

Reply
 

 
# Thinking isn't your stong point I seeGuest 2007-07-16 05:00
"the HDD can stream at 35.5MB/Sec [for a normal SATA],combined with Blu-ray speed stream at about 9MB/sec [PS3 can use both,as ID Tech 5 will have the abiltity to stream from both]"



Yes I know this, but it seems you don;t know that the use of the HDD in the 360 is NOT excluded on the 360, as Oblivion shows (something you're obviously unaware of).



MS *prefers* devs keep the use of the HDD to a minimum on the 360, that way avoiding devs being tempted to require games to dump GBs of data onto the HDD to improve performance, they'd rather devs use every means possible to get the best performance they can out of DVD, and THEN if necessary, use the HDD (as Bethesda did).



Why is the concept of an optional use of the HDD so difficult for you to comprehend?

Reply
 

 
# f*** offGuest 2007-07-16 05:11
u r one hell of a dumbass. And what the hell r u talking about.



"the fact is that the gameplay doesnt look like the trailer"



For what game? the E3 07 trailer of killzone 2 was gameplay. STFU

Reply
 

 
# No it isn'tGuest 2007-07-16 05:15
That's about Kojima not being impressed by the PS3 price cut and the possibility of MGS4 on the 360. It's not a topic about the game.

Reply
 

 
# Better, much improvedGuest 2007-07-16 05:37
KZ 2 is much improved from the 1st trailer. Warhawk on the other hand, has been coming out for over 12 months now, However the graphics and just the overall look of the game do not impress me. It looks like they enhanced a PS2 title and crossed it over to the PS3. I'm still looking forward for a PS3 title that holds the graphics, feel and overall look of Gears of War. I hate M$ but damn that game was graphically innovative!

Reply
 

 
# Hmmm, not that I want to interrupt you two but...Guest 2007-07-16 05:41
The_Regulator wrote: " [Hand-on of mass effect] that the game has many pop-ups,slow down and lag issues....when asking the development team,they attributed these to the DVD drive [meaning the game has to run on the core sku,they cant make the HDD a requiremnt it has to stream from the slow DVD]"



And then wrote; "go read the IGN on Mass effect/GTA4 Lag,and pop-ups".



It's a little dishonest to suggest that lag and pop-ups in these two games are all down to the DVD drive the_Regulator, especially since MANY other games shown at E3 suffered from exactly the same problems, including those on the PS3. This is to be expected since the games are not finished and therefore have months of optimisations to be done.



Also, the devs for Mass Effect did not attribute ALL those problems to the DVD drive, they simply stated that as ONE issue effecting the game, but it clearly wasn't the only issue. So again, I find your assessment rather dishonest, because you know full well that these are problems which are always present in unfinished games, and therefore is not purely the result of using DVD and no hard drive.



Ok, I'll leave you two to continue.

Reply
 

 
# oh shootGuest 2007-07-16 05:45
i forgot that gears of war is porting over to pc which is going to have more chapters and whatnot. man i wish halo 1 and 2 didnt port over to pc. that probably means the game that i think about when i stick the controller up my ass (halo 2 hd) is probably going to port on pc as well. man... sorry sony fans, i guess i really am a dumb ass.

Reply
 

 
# Great.Guest 2007-07-16 05:55
Really looking forward to this game.

Reply
 

 
# ...Oner001 2007-07-16 06:03
http://www.gametrailers.com/player/22115.html



You lose...no common sense

Reply
 

 
# *Psssst* Can you hear a distance rumble?Guest 2007-07-16 06:04
That's the sound of a herd of PS3 fanboys heading this way.



They'll arrive soon. ;)

Reply
 

 
# Funny...Shatterdome 2007-07-16 06:05
Funny thing is, if these were two games being compared on competing consoles....people would be crying "E32K5 kicks 2k7's ass...OMG! it totally pownzors it in every way"



And they would be right, there is really no comparison past that both of these use polygons....other then that, E32K5 is still WAAAY better then the realtime demo....it's not "close" as lot's of you would like....



Right from the begining, the clouds destroy....then the faces destroy....then the fire effects destroy....then the amount of detail seen from the airs destroys, then the smoke effects (especially from the fired bazooka where the smoke spirals and twists) destroy.....EVERYTHING is at least twice as good in the 2K5 demo.....I don't think they came close.



The 2K5 demo got me super excited, and had be vowing to get a PS3 as it was ridiculously awesome....found out it was CG and re-thought my decision...



The KZ2 trailer from E32K7 did not inspire any awe in me what so ever....



A resounding meh...



Oh yeah, and if the game is being released in 2008, it's not "pre-pre-Alpha". firstly there is no such thing...if you have your engine running, can move through a level and complete objective, it's nearing the end of ALpha....pre-alpha is before you have any code and you are doing concepts still....



It's about to go beta, it better be, or there will be horrible balancing and bugs in the game.



Fable 2 is generally done, and now is going into a year of beta testing and balancing/bug fixing....so you better hope KZ2 is doing the same...



(btw, that means don't expect many improvements.....even gears looked like it did a year before release, just with wacky framerates)

Reply
 

 
# OuchGuest 2007-07-16 06:12
That's all i can say about the angry exchanges here, but that said, Player97 has my vote (sorry the_ regulator, but you've proven yourself to be a sony fanboy, not just here but in other topics too).

Reply
 

 
# SAVE THE BS TILL YOU PLAY ITGuest 2007-07-16 06:21
FFS you can go on all day about the game \ababbaba

specs abbababa



sony would have had the game running off a dev

kit ffs with 2x the ram of stock ps3 just to start and whats not to say ?

that 2 3 4 dev kits are not link to make it run smooth as hell in 1080p or Trip out dev kit you never know with them .

SO stfu when get to play it on your ! ps3 then comment

Reply
 

 
# ummGuest 2007-07-16 06:49
DAMN!!! HOW AM I GONNA DOWNLOAD THIS?!

Reply
 

 
# wellGuest 2007-07-16 07:48
The PS3 supposedly already surpassed Gears with the UT3 demo released a while ago. But for sure, no retail PS3 game has done it, but I guess what matters is that the graphics bar set by Gears is kind of a thing of the past(probably for both systems).

Reply
 

 
# THANK YOUGuest 2007-07-16 08:39
"So again, I find your assessment rather dishonest, because you know full well that these are problems which are always present in unfinished games, and therefore is not purely the result of using DVD and no hard drive."



Exactly. It's common sense, something this guy obviously lacks.



And thanks 'The ONE' (I'll vote for you next time ;)).

Reply
 

 
# you have no basis for argumentGuest 2007-07-16 10:01
ps3 theoreticaly CAN do pre-renderer quality graphics

utilizing all seven cores of the cpu, a bit slowly though,but game developers can surpass that with "clever" coding.

how cool is that?

Reply
 

 
# So can the 360...Guest 2007-07-16 10:29
...by whatever judgement you've defining as pre-rendered quality graphics on the PS3.



These are both great consoles, but let's not get carried away please. ;)

Reply
 

 
# Mister Common whatever...Guest 2007-07-16 10:34
You really need to get laid (and your Mom doesn't count!)

Reply
 

 
# ~Guest 2007-07-16 10:45
Neither does your sister !!

Reply
 

 
# wat!!!Guest 2007-07-16 10:48
i have gow and it does not have the same graphics as killzone. killzonee eats gears for breakfast.

Reply
 

 
# omfgGuest 2007-07-16 10:50
why is mister common ***** sucker in every ps3 blog??



'when will it be relesed?Next year?Have fun waiting even longer'

That all you got against the ps3??

gears of war can be done on the ps3. matter fact halo and gears of wars are NOT made by microsoft. they were bought.2006 was 360 year; 2007 wii; next year ps3.what games does 360?? beside halo??? If sony wanted they could buy gears of war. who knows?? gears of war 2 might come out for the ps3.

Reply
 

 
# yes 360 can do 1080pGuest 2007-07-16 10:57
but, you need a 360 elite and it isnt true high def.

Reply
 

 
# lolGuest 2007-07-16 11:10
and u obviously can't see a thing

Reply
 

 
# rightGuest 2007-07-16 11:17
gears looks great and its fun but u will see better on 360 and ps3 but killzones graphics are better

Reply
 

 
# Because the guy's an idiotGuest 2007-07-16 11:21
"why is mister common ***** sucker in every ps3 blog??"



He likes nothing more than to start arguements whenever he can. In fact, I've yet to see him make a valuable contribution to any topic, all he does is spread fanboy b*llsh*t. Afterall, it's easier to destroy than to create.



But he's not the only one, there are some Sony fanboys on QJ who are no better than he is (which one in this topic thread in fact).



Sad but true. :(

Reply
 

 
# wtf..im here..lolGuest 2007-07-16 11:28
the 360 fanboys are comin!!!the 360 fanboys are comin!!!the 360 fanboys are comin!!!

lol. i admit . im a ps3 fanboy my self.

Reply
 

 
# You're incorrect dopeyGuest 2007-07-16 11:39
The regular 360s have had 1080p since the firmware update last year, and some lucky 360 gamers can achieve 1080p over component, the rest over VGA, and now those with the 360 Elite can achieve it over HDMI.



The built-in hardware upscaler doesn't stop 1080p being 'true' 1080p, so it's as 'true' on the 360 as it is the PS3. The upscaler makes it easy for lower res games (i.e. 720p) to be upscaled to 1080p, however games need to be written to take advantage on 1080p natively, and the 360 has a number of those already.



eg;



http://www.seganerds.com/2007/02/06/virtua-tennis-3-for-xbox-360-in-1080p



http://arstechnica.com/journals/thumbs.ars/2007/2/8/6956



From my understanding, the only restriction is 30fps at 1080p (by combining the two interlaced fields of 1080i at 60fps into one field at 30fps).



Hence it looks no different than 1080p games on the PS3 running at 30fps! So the real difference is, the PS3 is capable of 1080p at 60fps for certain games (where the graphical compromise is not a big issue).

Reply
 

 
# ^^^^Guest 2007-07-16 11:55
yeah thats true. no 60 fps on 1080p for 360...

Reply
 

 
# ...Guest 2007-07-16 12:02
The only thing better in the real-time one is the blood splatter effects which I think they should have included in the comparison

Reply
 

 
# whyGuest 2007-07-16 12:24
why do you guys even reply to this guy, hes just posted here to stir things up.

Reply
 

 
# ^^^^ Yeah player97Guest 2007-07-16 12:56
It's great to see someone here who knows what he's talking about and can say it without acting like a fanboy (certain people should take note).



Personally, I didn't know how 1080p was achieved on the 360 (1080i@60fps converted to 1080p@30fps), but it makes complete sense now. I knew the upscaler chip upscaled 1080i to 1080p, which it does, but I now understand it creates a genuine 1080p image by combining the odd and even scan lines of two 1080i fields, hence a maximum framerate of 30fps for 1080p (60fps for 1080i). Yep, I get it now. :)



Thanks for the info.

Reply
 

 
# Ha, im still laughingGuest 2007-07-16 13:07
Well well well, Sony's alleged "Halo Killer" eh? If this is the same team who brought the first Killzone then this game will be crap. Other than the graphics (which are pretty good) i dont know what there is to be excited about, the gameplay in the first killzone was hard, choppy, and uneven. What makes you think the gameplay in Killzone 2 will be any better. What is online play be like? what about splitscreen multiplayer or coop? How about downloadable content? If Guitar Hero III was a Playstation exclusive it would be more popular than this.



And for you fools who think Halo 3 is crap well your just a plain ignoramous.



After taking an extensive look at Halo 3 I must say the graphics have been given a complete overhaul, much better textures, lighting, god ray's, water effects are "holy crap, look at that!" good, a lot more things are destructible this time around ( the bigger covanent ships, the covenant walker ), realistic debree is everywhere. The music is played in such a way that the awesome blood pumping song's wont stop if you take too long. More vehicles, The online play was top notch in the Beta, with you being able to save clips and watch them to see how much ass you kicked.



In the Halo 3 you can save your video (up to 100), watch it from any prospective, change the camera angle, slow down time, speed time up, and all kinds of other cool techniques. You also have the ability to take your own screenshots (up to 50) and swap movies back and forth from your friends online.



you can veto the first map/gametype that pops up in multiplayer matches which is very useful if you hate the map or gametype, In the Beta there was little lag, and always people online (PS3 owners will be lucky to find 3 million total online users for Killzone, us Xbox owners will easily have 6 million people online and probably close to 1 million people online everyday.



And as far as universes go Halo has a much more diverse and well structred universe when compared to Killzones destoryed theme.



I look at Halo 3 and see a champion, and besides which do you think will be more popular for Major League Gamers? The first Killzone didnt beat Halo 2. If your wondering why Xbox360 fans are on your forums ruining your fun is...well...because we have you guys in our forums.

Reply
 

 
# ......Guest 2007-07-16 15:19
this makes you forget about Gears of war and that ***** series Halo :)

Reply
 

 
# I realize IGN sucks, but...Guest 2007-07-16 15:43
Seeing as how it's the most popular video game site, using it to compare video game "hotness" is logical.



http://www.ign.com/



Killzone 2: #8, Halo 3: #1. 'Nuff said



Just so no one can say anything, here's the second most popular game site:



http://www.gamespot.com/



Killzone 2: Not in the top 10, Halo 3: #1. Again, 'nuff said

Reply
 

 
# killer?Guest 2007-07-16 16:46
360 fan here and ps3 owner.



this game looks better in almost everyway to halo3, but there will prob be 5million copies of h3 sold before this game is even released. Microsoft/halo3 will have nothing to worry from this game. Halo3 will be played by millons in just 2 months while many of us PS3 owners are having to wait till next year for the H3killer.



Kinda like the forza2 and granTourismo5 fighting. Yes GT5 looks better and prob will be better but we can play forza2 now.



now no one needs to flame me, hell i dont even care if you believe me but i do own both consoles, i only care about games not the devices that play them. simple fact is the 360 gives me more good games sooner as i keep finding myself waiting for the PS3 titles but at least it looks like sony is going to deliver

Reply
 

 
# ehAoxomamoxoA 2007-07-16 16:59
It looks just ok, but if it plays like Resistance then Im gonna pass. The textures in this need updating badly!!



You people dissing Halo and whatnot are pathetic. Just let people play what they want to play. If you dont like Halo then good for you, but no one cares what you have to say if youre not a fan. Much like how you dont care what Xbox fans say about PS3, youre still going to continue to play the PS3. Halo might not be your style, but for 10mil or so people out there it is.

Reply
 

 
# ...Guest 2007-07-16 18:30
please change ur name to Mister No Common Sense! NOW!

Reply
 

 
# i thinkGuest 2007-07-16 19:44
resistance wasn't that bad and it was basically the exact same as halo1 or halo 2 except with sick graphics.



yeah halo 1 was like the best game ever, halo 2 was good but the same story line and i presume halo 3 is going to be very similar.



i don't have an xbox but i have clocked halo 1 and halo 2 and they are pretty much the same which is good but a bit repetitive.



Microsoft is getting all the exclusives which is gay for the ps3 but it has only been out for like 5 months and resistance was just as good graphics as most xbox games but had better textures.



i will look forward to playing halo 3 but it better have some new stuff. oh yeah and the reason there are so many jumps and comments on halo 3 is because it has every xbox fan behind it and we all know that there are like a billion xbox fans.

Reply
 

 
# oh yeah...Guest 2007-07-16 19:48
lol all that and i forgot to talk about the video.

i reckon the 2k5 had better explosions and fire but the 2k7 was pwnage in every way (apart from texture which still pwned anyway. of course the pr is better but killzone still has like another year.

Reply
 

 
# SchooledGuest 2007-07-16 19:50
I agree with lots of things that Player97 is saying.Why is player97 schooling all of you guys in this discussion, and he isn't even being a fanboy. Just shows how much some of you fanboys know about both consoles.

Reply
 

 
# i pwned everyoneGuest 2007-07-16 20:35
this is your brain:

_____

| :|

| PS3 :|

| |

|_____|

this is your brain on drugs:

_____

| :|

| xbox :|

| 360 |

|_____|

Reply
 

 
# OkayGuest 2007-07-16 21:39
Only person you pwned is yourself buddy



I agree with AoxomamoxoA, why do some of you care what other people like to play? How does it affect you at all? Do you have that little of a life that you have to tell people (on the Internet no less) that they are stupid or lesser than you because they play a game that is arguably better than what you play?



Besides, you're typically just wasting your time. I hate FF and think it's gotten to be same-old same-old, but I'm not going to waste my time telling a FF fan how much FF sucks because they don't care. So just keep it to yourself.

Reply
 

 
# Looking forwardGuest 2007-07-17 00:53
I think KZ2 looks good, as I am sure H3 will be, but i prefer the much more sophisticated looking UT3!

Reply
 

 
# YepGuest 2007-07-17 04:14
'Player 97' owned 'The_Regulator' over and over again. :D

Reply
 

 
# huh?Guest 2007-07-17 07:36
Don't you mean: "You Sony fans can talk all the tech you want!! The fact is that the game play doesn't look like the trailer!! In fact, Gears of War looks better!! As for Halo 3, it looks better already and it's not even the full game; They've just shown a demo that will most likely look better by launch in September!! So all the tech talk doesn't matter because the proof is in what we see!!"?



Well I have something to say about that. Are you a *****ing idiot? Don't most people learn how to spell in 1st grade? The way you talk about Halo 3 leads me to believe that you've never played the beta, have you? the graphics aren't better than any other Xbox 360 game I've seen. And that goes doubly for Gears of War. Basing my judgment purely on what I've seen in the real time trailer, i can honestly say that I think Killzone 2's graphics are hella better than Halo 3's. (Yes, I've played the beta. Yes the $60 was worth it, but only because it came with Crackdown. Three maps (one of them sucks, alot.), a new vehicle, a few extra weapons (spikers, brute grenades, laser, portable turret, missle pod launcher, etc...) the active camo isn't worth *****, the man cannon isn't very different than the teleporter except you get a look at the whole battlefield, the mongoose is a piece of crap, the bubble shield is pretty cool, the portable grav lift is awesome, the power drainer is gay, the controls are kind of weird at first(serperate reloads for dual weild, LB and RB, and X is for equipment, talking is Up on the D-pad.)



You're arguement for this will probably be similar to: "yeah, but halo 3 will sell more and be more fun"



From what I've seen I think Killzone 2 looks like more fun, and IMO the multiplayer probably won't be disappointing.



argue all you want, everything i stated about killzone is purely opinion, and about halo 3 as well.

Reply
 

 
# to all the pplGuest 2007-07-17 08:36
that say that the ps3 games dont look as good as xbox 360 games....The xbox has been out for over a year and soon the ps3 will surpase the xbox. Just like in at launch some 360 games did look that great. This is not a sony fan boy talking just someone whos annoyed with all this arguing. I think the ps3 grahpics can only get better soon games will just as good if not better then that e3 05 trailer just watch.

Reply
 

 
# ^^^ NopeGuest 2007-07-17 12:08
The two consoles will always be about even in terms of graphics (it has nothing to do with how long the consoles have been out, especially since the PS3 was delayed 6-9 months). PS3 characters will never have the number of polygons and detail seen in the E3 2005 trailer for Killzone, since we're not talking about a console with 4GB of video memory. It will ALWAYS use far less polygons with detail added through textures and techniques like normal mapping.



Besides, the graphics will continue to get better for *both* the 360 and PS3.



You say you are annoyed with all this argueing, but then you go and add fuel to the fire!

Reply
 

 
# Well...Guest 2007-07-17 12:17
...firstly, Xman is an idiot, but just the same...



"Basing my judgment purely on what I've seen in the real time trailer, i can honestly say that I think Killzone 2's graphics are hella better than Halo 3's. (Yes, I've played the beta..."



The purpose of the Halo 3 beta was to test the network code, game balance and identify bugs. It was not a graphics test, hence it was stripped down compared to the single player game (like the multplayer option of many games).



Read the previews of those who saw Halo 3 single player being played at E3. The conclusion of all is that it's a beautiful looking game, significantly better than what we saw in the beta, and better than the trailer shown this year (which doesn't really do the game justice).



As you said, it's all opinion, but I do think you should be comparing like with like, i.e. H3 single player vs Killzone 2 single player (which is difficult for us because of no H3 sp videos being released).

Reply
 

 
# shut the f*** upGuest 2007-07-18 00:21
bloody hell this is a killzone video not a 360 video where the ***** did the 360ers come from. dont you have anything better to do god talk about killzone not halo 3 and how much it pwns this and that god.



anyway i reackon the 2k7 pwns the 2k5 apart from fire and frame rate

Reply
 

 
# Try reading next timeGuest 2007-07-18 01:19
If you actually _read_ this thread, you'll see it's the PS3 fanboys who keep bringing up Halo 3 and how Killzone pwns it, with the first coming from The_Regulator (read his first post)! So of course gamers are going to respond, why shouldn't they?



And imo, Killzone 2K5 easily owns Killzone 2K7 BTW. ;)

Reply
 

Add comment

Security code
Refresh


Welcome to QJ.Net!

If you want your comments to go live without waiting for moderation, you need to be logged in. Being logged in has its benefits:
  • Logged in members do not wait for their comments to be approved.
  • Logged in members can create Profiles to be seen by other users.
So why wait? Create an account or login now! It's easy, quick, and free.

To get started, use the LOGIN boxes, or the REGISTER link below!



Want to learn more about the team who brings you the QJ news?

Read about them now!


RSS Feeds Follow us on Twitter Find us on Facebook
Login:

HOT FLASH GAMES

Monster Truck Jumper

Left to Die

The Empire 2

Dark Dimension

Town Drift Competition

Heroes of the Sword