Portable Console Online War: PSP vs. DS

Posted Apr 5, 2006 at 8:41PM by QJ Staff Listed in: News, Featured Articles Tags: Japan, Pictochat, PlayStation Network, Sony
Ó


The PSP and Nintendo DS war is far from over. Just a week ago, Alaric S. blogged about the current status of PSP and DS in terms of units sold in Japan and in the US. There was no clear winner in that category and has obviously gotten all of you heated up. GameDaily.com has an interesting article that pits PSP against the Nintendo yet again, but this time looking into one of the most revered features of the handheld consoles, online capabilities.

The Nintendo DS seems to be doing something right with its free Wi-Fi Service that keeps gamers connected, making things more interactive. And with the release of Metroid Prime: Hunters and Tetris DS, the online link up has just gotten a big boost. Although the DS is on the right track, a few more features  won't hurt. GameDaily suggested expanding the PictoChat to include features that work more on clans or a few customizations. It's just a small add-on that targets gamers who really like to hook up with other gamers, but in general  it may not be all that neccesary. Another idea is to expand the game support setup by offering some kind of online download service, which will resurrect classic Nintendo games we love. This may actually see the light of day with its possible tie-in with the Revolution's Virtual Console service. If Nintendo wants to get a lot of online participation, it should offer tournaments and celebrity plays, and while they're at it, add more hot spots too.

Over at Sony, the PSP seems to have gotten the edge in gaming quality. Sony is also doing the right thing with the availability of PS One games for download on the PSP (later this year).  This move just might pave the way for a full-on gaming network that will push for greater online play. GameDaily says: Sony's easily got the resources and finances to set themselves up a service along the likes of Xbox Live and Nintendo's Wi-Fi Connection. Maybe the PlayStation Network is the answer, but so far, it seems to heavily support the PS3. What Sony should do here is provide some kind of push that allows for greater connection of online play across the board, without having to really deal with set-up issues or worrying about trying to find a buddy. Ease of service would really make this a smooth running machine, and a dedicated network would be the answer.

With both PSP and DS doing the right thing with what they currently have, it's what they need to improve on that will make this war even more interesting. The handheld that will bring online gaming to the next level will surely emerge as the winner.



 
 
 

Comments

by - 2006-04-05 21:28:57
WHAT HAPPENED TO THE INTERNETS?

No immature flame war in the comments? There may yet be hope for humanity!
by - 2006-04-05 21:31:44
DUH?!?

DS: 1% (GAME PLAY) PSP: 99% (WERE SHOULD I START?)
by - 2006-04-05 21:31:54
DUH?!?

DS: 1% (GAME PLAY) PSP: 99% (WERE SHOULD I START?)
by - 2006-04-05 21:34:06
Well, it lasted 3 minutes at least

nocomment
by Aryn The Cat - 2006-04-05 21:56:02
Just a suggestion...

One feasible suggestion for a feature would be to make sure the upcoming Flash support has adequate support for Flash games. That way, people who want to program games and applications for the PSP can do so under the restrictions of Flash content, which will increase the overall appeal of the PSP to people who do not own one yet and make SONY appear to be more "user friendly" towards PSp owners while causing more people who still use 1.5 PSP systems which could be used to pirate PSP games to update. This will not really hurt game sales either since flash games could not come close to matching the quality of commercial PSP games. That way, the only people who would lose out would be those who love emulators and pirate PSP games, people can program all they want without hacking the PSP, and more people will be happier in the end. This would definitely give Nintendo a run for their money too.
by Aryn The Cat - 2006-04-05 21:57:54
Just a suggestion...

One feasible suggestion for a feature would be to make sure the upcoming Flash support has adequate support for Flash games. That way, people who want to program games and applications for the PSP can do so under the restrictions of Flash content, which will increase the overall appeal of the PSP to people who do not own one yet and make SONY appear to be more "user friendly" towards PSp owners while causing more people who still use 1.5 PSP systems which could be used to pirate PSP games to update. This will not really hurt game sales either since flash games could not come close to matching the quality of commercial PSP games. That way, the only people who would lose out would be those who love emulators and pirate PSP games, people can program all they want without hacking the PSP, and more people will be happier in the end. This would definitely give Nintendo a run for their money too.
by - 2006-04-06 02:41:15
good idea's

if nintendo make snes/nes/gba emu etc.. available for DS then i will buy a DS and upgrade my psp to 3.0
by - 2006-04-06 03:38:06
psp's online games suck U_U

Im suprised they dident mension nintendo ds's online gamers out number psp's online gamers 17 too 1. psp's wifi games suck and have yet to bring barrley any people in at all. wile nintendo ds has more people on there service then then freiken halo. Im sorry soney fans psp's online games suck and arnt bringing in a croud like nintendo ds's online service. im not a fanboy and im just telling you the truth about how the 2 systems stack up.
by - 2006-04-06 04:07:32
DUMB

DUMB DUMB DUMB DUMB PSP AND DS CAN NOT AND NEVER WILL BE COMPARABLE PERIOD the psp is good but with the expensive titles and the short games, it quickly losing fire. homebrew for psp is starting to fade away. nothing new has come out but the streamers. and for those pople starting to devolp, PLEASE MAKE A FUN FIRST GAME OR DONT MAE ONE AT ALL
by - 2006-04-06 04:51:25
wot?

PSP online games suck??? Ever heard of SOCOM you turd???
by - 2006-04-06 05:55:57
PSP Online is great

Ds has decent online but the psp isnt bad either..and for your information way more people play halo then all the ds games combined.. but not all of them use xboxlive some use other services.
by - 2006-04-06 05:59:43
PSP online

There's PSP online games? I'm sure they're not as good as the DS's online games.
by - 2006-04-06 08:43:50
"Over at Sony, the PSP seems to have gotten the edge in gaming quality."

Umm... no. Both systems have great games, but the DS still clearly has more "must own" software than the PSP. They're both worth owning though.
by zodionic - 2006-04-06 09:31:47
ds 64, road to success?

hey, would it not be a great ideo to bring out "classic" games to the ds like the gba did with nes, but have n64 games. ok they have mario, but it would be stunning to see zelda ocarina of time or goldeneye on a handheld, and the could also add in some cool touch screen features to make the game worth buying. theres so much talk about the ds having better games than the psp, but in my opinion there both not as cool as games used to be, bring back good games!
by - 2006-04-06 09:57:12
***** you guys

Theres no *****ing competition. This is like judging a old school Mac PC with a current Windows XP. The hardware is far superior/ This is a stupid *****ing post. We all know whats better. Drop it. The origanal gameboy has sold more than the current one. Does that mean its better? NO! STFU!
by - 2006-04-06 09:57:33
***** you guys

Theres no *****ing competition. This is like judging a old school Mac PC with a current Windows XP. The hardware is far superior/ This is a stupid *****ing post. We all know whats better. Drop it. The origanal gameboy has sold more than the current one. Does that mean its better? NO! STFU!
by - 2006-04-06 10:05:31
so i own both

i like both systems mucho... psp is better overall and the games have great replay value... ds is good for online... mario kart is the best game for online... in mario kart connections online don't fail... can't say that for psp madden 06 though...
by - 2006-04-06 10:50:57
Typo in Article

not to be picky or anything but at the beginning of the article u put "pits" :-) as opposed to "puts"
by - 2006-04-06 11:20:23
DS...blah

i havent yet played a good DS game...not even metriod, it wasnt great at all.
by - 2006-04-06 12:39:12
aaaaaaaaaah

i needn yo momma
by - 2006-04-06 13:07:36
PSP v's DS lolololololol

Your joking right?............. No your not! Get a grip. What's the saying..... Like comparing Apples (PSP) to ROTTEN ORANGES (DS).
by drunkenmonky - 2006-04-06 13:48:37
ds vs psp

sony fanboys make me laugh. psp has no good games thats why i run homebrew on it. but the ds all the games i have a good. stop being so blinded buy your love for a company and get a real game not a umd movie
by drunkenmonky - 2006-04-06 13:52:56
ds vs psp

sony fanboys make me laugh. psp has no good games thats why i run homebrew on it. but the ds all the games i have a good. stop being so blinded buy your love for a company and get a real game not a umd movie
by - 2006-04-06 15:30:43
Quality eh?

I hardly think the PSP is leading the 'quality' games. I stopped caring about the psp game releases fairly quickly, because in all honesty, they all suck, or are rehashes of ps2 games/series. Now, I own a DS, a PSP and an Xbox 360. So far, almost every game released for the psp has been something I'd rather play on a console, since the loading times are rediculous in general for people on the go, and there is a distinct lack of 'save now->quit' functions. In short. Thank god for homebrew. PMP player is my god, as well as all of the emulation software out to make my gaming experience entertaining, as opposed to a progress bar battery life battle.
by - 2006-04-06 19:08:54
.

"sony fanboys make me laugh. psp has no good games thats why i run homebrew on it. but the ds all the games i have a good. stop being so blinded buy your love for a company and get a real game not a umd movie" Agreed. But with homebrew psp is better. Without, DS (I own both stupid fanboys).
by - 2006-04-06 23:55:28
drunkenmonky

24. ยป ds vs psp sony fanboys make me laugh. psp has no good games thats why i run homebrew on it. but the ds all the games i have a good. stop being so blinded buy your love for a company and get a real game not a umd movie ****** well YEAH, all the games I HAVE are good too. and yet, i don't have a DS. you'd have to like a game to buy it, correct? fanboyism includes you too. afterall, you like the DS, don't you? just as I like the PSP. whoop-de-do. "so stop be blinded" by your fairly obvious hatred for a company, and let people buy what THEY like.

Add New Comment




You must be logged in to post comments




Add QJ.NET
Add to My Yahoo!
Google Reader Subscribe with Bloglines
Add  to your Kinja digest Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Subscribe with Pluck RSS reader Add 'www.qj.net' to Newsburst from CNET News.com
Subscribe with SearchFox RSS del.icio.us www.qj.net
Add to Technorati Favorite! Add to My AOL
furl! it Stumble for Treehugger!