Quick Jump Daily Digest

Thank you for your interest in the Quick Jump Daily Digest. Get notified of all new content on QJ in our free Daily Digest. To subscribe, enter your email address below and click the subscribe button.


Email Address:


Email will come from "donotreply@caputomedia.com". Please whitelist this email address.

Cancel and Return to page

PoV: Notch Can Use Scrolls. Woo.

Posted Feb 14, 2012 at 12:45PM EST by Mr Pham

Listed in: News Tags: mojang law suit, notch vs bethesda, scrolls case
Ó

 

This a PoV. In other words, this article is my point of view, and while you may disagree with it, learn to embrace it. It's Valentine's Day. Opinions and love are what keep the world going (Probably). Not that this article will be filled with love.


Something about Notch bothers me. An air of arrogance? Maybe.

 

Bethesda aren't happy with his use of the name ‘Scrolls’ on his new game, but instead of changing it, he let things go to court and has indeed won an injunction that will now let him use the name unless/until Bethesda appeal against it.

 

NOTCH

 

 

Hope you’re happy, Notch, as it doesn't feel like a victory to me. I understand he wasn't happy with Bethesda trying to own a word, and I agree with him being upset; you can’t own a common word.

 

But if he had changed his title’s name as soon as Bethesda had complained, it would have worked much more in his favour. Why? Because people would say:

 

‘Why did he change the name?’

 

‘Because Bethesda weren't happy with it because they use the word in The Elder Scrolls.’

 

‘Wow, Bethesda are dicks.’

 

Instead it’s ‘Notch beat Bethesda in that name case. Oh good, after the months and hassle of law suits, he gets to use the world ‘Scrolls’.’

 

And they’d be right. It feels like he’s trying to prove a point to everyone watching, so he’s the big indie man taking down the evil corporations.

 

I’m just not feeling the passion here, it feels primarily about status.

 

Your views?



40% of voters think this story ROCKS!
Vote Now!    This story ROCKS! (2) This story SUCKS!! (3)




Become a Member of QJ.Net!

If you want your comments to go live without waiting for moderation, you need to be logged in. Being logged in has its benefits:
  • Logged in members do not wait for their comments to be approved.
  • Logged in members can sign up for nightly updates.
  • Logged in members can create Profiles to be seen by other users.
So why wait? Create an account or login now! It's easy, quick, and free.

To get started, use the LOGIN boxes, or the REGISTER link at the top right!

Comments 


 
# .triac 2012-02-14 15:02
So basically:
If a large company approaches you and makes ridiculous demands: Do whatever they say.

Reply
 

 
# RE: .Mr Pham 2012-02-14 17:01
Depends on the demand; change the title of a small title, then yes. Since the company is so large, everyone will know what happened and you'll benefit more from the public eye than going through publicized court battles for one word.
Now it looks like a petty battle with both sides being, well, petty.
If he had changed it, Bethesda would have come across petty, and Notch would have come across as not caring over a simple change.

Reply
 

 
# RE: RE: .AkaiOtoko 2012-02-14 21:14
Didn't Medal of Honor(was it?) get bashed by gamers because they didn't fight for keeping content?

I assume that had Notch given up on the name they would do the same.

Either way, they both would have still looked "petty".

Reply
 

 
# RE: RE: RE: .Mr Pham 2012-02-15 09:34
Possibly; I don't recall the Medal Of Honor thing, but if that was their reaction, then there's no pleasing gamers!

Reply
 

 
# Seriously?roflcoptor 2012-02-14 20:59
So because someone didn't want to change the title of a game that they were making, and by all rights should be able to call it anything that they so please, and won a court battle, you think he is petty? HIGH-LAIR-E-US!

Reply
 

 
# ttenf 2012-02-15 18:51
Wow, you people are stupid. I thought it was established MONTHS ago that if Notch copyrighted the word "Scrolls" that he could then sue Bethesda for every Elder Scrolls game released afterwards. THIS IS JUST LAWYERS BEING LAWYERS, THIS WAS OVER MONTHS AGO. NOTCH IS A MONEY GRUBBING ASSHOLE.

Reply
 

 
+1 # Not winning...SoDumb 2012-02-17 23:24
Notch did not even want to go to court. Don't you remember when he asked for a game off between Bethesda & Mojang - whoever won would decide if Scrolls could be used on his next game. Bethesda's lawyers slapped that peaceful idea down hard.

I've been a Bethesda fan for over a decade, but they were crossing the line with this court business. Consumers aren't stupid. Scrolls is abviously unrelated to The Elder Scrolls. I doubt Bethesda will release an ELDER Scrolls game without the word ELDER in it.

Reply
 

 
+1 # Maybe they arebykfiend42 2012-02-20 15:42
Anyone who thinks consumers aren't stupid hasn't worked in retail. I've watched several confused people try to buy those generic Disney movie knockoffs, like Aladdin where the genie is red. A name similarity to someone who is just buying a game based on recommendation may cause them to buy Scrolls thinking it's Elder Scrolls. A lot of knockoff companies bank on the fact that people don't pay attention and there are plenty of lazy consumers.

Reply
 

Add comment

Security code
Refresh


Welcome to QJ.Net!

If you want your comments to go live without waiting for moderation, you need to be logged in. Being logged in has its benefits:
  • Logged in members do not wait for their comments to be approved.
  • Logged in members can create Profiles to be seen by other users.
So why wait? Create an account or login now! It's easy, quick, and free.

To get started, use the LOGIN boxes, or the REGISTER link below!



Want to learn more about the team who brings you the QJ news?

Read about them now!


RSS Feeds Follow us on Twitter Find us on Facebook
Login:

HOT FLASH GAMES

Ben10 Ultimatrix Scepter

Insane Truckers

Ultimate Racing

Ultimate Rally Challenge 08

Captain Zorro Last Hope

High School Tower Defense

Newest Downloads

05/21/2012 - 05/26/2012

05/25/2012
05/24/2012
05/24/2012
05/24/2012
05/22/2012
05/22/2012
05/22/2012
05/22/2012
05/21/2012
05/21/2012
05/19/2012
05/19/2012
05/19/2012
05/18/2012
05/18/2012


HOT GAMING NEWS TOPICS


POPULAR GAMING NEWS SEARCHES

psx 2 psp | ds gba | firmware psp 150 | fighnight round 4 | pronto code | ps3 hard drive | is loder | bubble | vlc media | mhp 3 | firefox | sd gecko | realplayer | pes 2011 patch | comics nintendo | sleep n wake psp | slipknot | czbvpkkosyxilcyk | dsc | frontier | professional gun | mega man legends 2 | article | nexus | cerpen ngentot | windows software of | emulation gba | justchris | girl and father | daedalusx64 games | ps3 controller drive | killzone 3 demo | action replay homebrew | 3d chess | pspgo fc | screenshot | devpsp | doc maker | ps2 vcs cheat | ir shell | dolphin svn r7630 32bit | nintendo d | speed test | nfs hot pursuit 2010 | ps3 sold more | neocd bios | upgrader | resident evil 4 psp | signed ps | piratraiders | psplayermt for psp | ptv | backtrack | universal psp | popsloader 660 | kamapisachi actress | gravity guy psp | jig | windows nintendo | modernwarfare 3 | fring | iphone uae | psx psp eboot packs | sims3 generations | tranfomers | skyward sword trailer | daedalusx64 | psp adhoc transfer file | prince of persia | super mario sunshine | does it cost money | psp opera mini | ps3 dualshock driver | emualator | dolphin svn build 2276 | rollingstone | unlock softwear | ps3 multiman | psp ydict | back up ploade | eds | snes emulator for ds | synth | playstation store h | psp sticker | cheat psp | offline | live | neocdpsp | ifreeradio | seplugins machine | mame n1001 | mgs 5 rising | opera on psp | dungeon siege allist | modpack and xexmenu | psp ir shell remote | psp power | psp homebrew hold | binary edi | dead head fred | macorfire | popsloader for prometheus | psp file maneger | driver | psp content | region changer | half life live action | erranigma | no regret | soft | dance dance revoluti | psp homebrew channel | usb forwarder | gta 3 real | meu | pandora tool for fat | chickhen speed | take two | freekey | final fantasy xiii | how to update | download homebrew | chicken r2 | nds facebook | psp home brew apps | sound recorder | pspconstructor | how to jailbrek ipad 2 | psp emulator mario | sms and sgg emulators | gen | psn spring sales | learn jp | ps3 blinking red light | hen gen firmware | psp mac address chan | playstation 2 controller | how to install popsloader 660 | djmax | toy story 3 | konami | ps3 network | ps3 homebrew apps | geekos | fix the psp shutdown | psp homebrew battery | housewife | mgs5 | eyepet cfw psp | powerpoint ds | install homebrew cha | quakegx | hack psp 2001 | snes9xw gx | top driving games | ds comics | dragon ball z videos | evil outbreak | how to get to relic castle | c64 | ultimate psp | wii homebrew easy | nano 6g | root | dead island gameplay | 660 pro b | red ring | mac shell psp | n p z | xgen v5 updater | customhome beta | cache v22 | sense me in psp | emulator nintendo 64 |