|
|
|
|
[Via Gamespot]
Permalink |
Email this |
Linking Blogs
| Digg It!
Bookmark / Find this article on: |
|
61 Comments
|
That has got to be one of the stupidest laws ever. I hope the ESA succeeds in fighting this.
what a *****. its as bad as arny saying that videogames are too violent.
Presumably you have laws in the US restricting minors' access to mature-rated movies, right?
So why are videogames different? If all it took to get the likes of Jack Thompson to shut up was to actually respect the age ratings given to games, wouldn't that be worth it?
Why is it right that a 5-year-old should be allowed to buy a zombie gore-fest like Resident Evil?
It just seems strange to me that gamers in the US seem hell-bent on the right of their kids to buy inappropriate games.
I don't see anything wrong with this law. Kids shouldn't be playing violent video games anyway. YEA that's what I said, I'm ready to hear the flamming...
geez hope this doesnt go to aus man i feel srry anyways STOCK UP ON VIOLENCE GAMES BEFORE THE AUGUST 1st
So underage kids are currently allowed to my adult rated games in the US? Thats crazy. In the UK and in loads of other countries, if you're under 18 you CANNOT buy an 18 (equivalent of AO in the US) rated game. That seems fair, if I want an 18 rated game I just ask my parents to buy it. I don't get what the fuss is about. Im pretty sure in the US that you can't buy certain films if you're too young, so why should games be different?
SOMEONE GETS IT!
Thank you ESA!
I don't see where games affect young ppl or any other media for that fact, I was 3 and played bio menace I was 7 and played diablo and I was like 13 or 15 and played GTA, you expect me to wait one more year until I turn 18 to acctualy be able to play these games, I was never affected in a negative way by these games.
I said this more than once and I will say it again, the problem is that stupid kids shouldn't be able to play these games, I'm not stupid enough to go around killing people, and even if I did I wouldn't be stupid enough to do it like that guy.
If these people actually played games they would know for a fact that if you kill someone no-one knows about it it's crucial (Hitman anyone?), and where does a 16 year old get a gun please tell me because if 16 year olds can get guns than maybe games are not your biggest problem here.
I'm glad I played all those games, most of them I could only play next year and maybe then they would not be as much as fun.
Going back a little peaople are stupid, a person that cannot distinguish real from fantasy is just stupid and should not be allowed to have a GUN. I have a lot of friends that played games that are for ages above them and they didn't kill anyone, they didn't torture anyone. What the ***** is wrong with you, go find an ***** like this and give them a weapon, yeah now that is smart, hey he killed someone, it's because he played violent games, not because he had a wepon and was completely out of is mind confusing fantasy with reality.
oh and sorry for the long speech but these things piss me of.
How the hell do they expect to uphold this law? Place a cop outside every store that sells video games? Not to mention that if this doesn't go on any record then how can they expect a kid to pay? I'm all for keeping inappropriate games out of the hands of kids, but how does slapping them with a $25 charge do anything? As I said, I don't think kids belong playing GTA or such (I'm talking about an 8-10 year old; if you're thinking a 13-14 year old I don't have much objection to them playing GTA) but there will always be that kid who finds his daddy's Playboy before he knows what to do with it.
...here is why. In the US, we have a little thing called the constitution, which grants citizens freedoms. Freedoms of speech and freedoms of expression.
I have a three year old daughter. Would i let her play GTA? Nope. Should the government say she absolutely cannot play the game? Nope. That happening stops my right to be a parent and her right to choose. Is there any evidence that a child raised playing violent video games is more likely to be violent in reality? If not, then there should be no state tort imposed restrictions.
Are we to allow them to install cameras infront of the computer so they can monitor what she watches and turn it off if its been rated above a certain subjective maturity level? I hope to God not.
Thats bull. just bring ur parents to the game store problem solved. They cant stopu if ur dad is there with u.
WOOOOOW!!!!They would go as far as fining kids for their games....Well,why dont you go after the "violent" television shows that depicts violence in REALITY and get off your rags!!! Now thats the craziest f#####g thing ive ever heard!!!
Actually this is a great law.. The first law that was put into place in some other state, can't remember which, that said "no games with violence towards humans" could be sold to minors was silly. Zelda could be considered violent towards humans and that is a game partly geared towards kids. However, this law takes in the ESRB rating system and only prohibits the sale of Mature or Adults Only games.
Similarly, kids can not go into certain movies WITHOUT their parents buying them the tickets or going along with them. This is almost the same. Your kids can still play those games but the parents will have to buy it for them.
With today's technology (such as the PSP), it can even be difficult for parents to know if a kid bought a game they shouldn't have. Only way the kid can be caught is if the parents see them playing.
Moreover, it makes the parents be a little more part of the whole video game world. If they have to go to the store they are more likely to be informed and make better parenting decisions, where if there was no such law in place they might just give their kids money and let them buy whatever they want.
This isn't a law on our first amendment and if you think it is then you must really think the gov't is out to get you. Most laws like this don't bother people with an intelligence :)
http://www.docuworld.org/component/option,com_mtree/task,viewlink/link_id,228/Itemid,30/
stupid law. doesnt really do anything thats not being done now. for as long as the esrb ratings have been around. it has always been illegal to sell a m or ao rated game to a child.
but indeed there is absolutely nothing that can done if the parent buys it for their children. however the posting of esrb rating signs in all stores that sell video games is genius. i hardly ever see them except maybe in walmart where a sticker is pasted to the glass. but in depth descriptions are needed, whereas its only a few words describing what the rating means. too bad not too many parents care anyway. this law is bull*****. it does nothing to stop violent videogames from being in the hands of a child. absolutely nothing. it should be fought. and countered with something more relevant.
You show them ESA, no one will be stopping the Video Game violence as long as there is the right to freedom of speech.
Stick that in your pipe and smoke it...
it sucks. Why must the government try so hard to parent the children. well, i think that the government should get out of parents' business. Hey, maybe there should be a "parents against jack" forum
Way to go ESA! The government too often regulates what children do. Meanwhile, adults, who may be bums or be on steroids, are allowed to buy violent video games
guess what another attack on video games is out there? Apparently, microsoft flight simulator trained the 9/11 hijackers, according to a guy who presented at my school! Shoulda got his name...now games that are too realistic like sims should be destroyed
If you read it, it says if the minor BUYS the game. Children shouldn't have access to these games with an adult. If the parent lets them play it, then its fine.
Now, if it were just for possessing it, then there would be a serious breach of freedom.
Let's say that I'm 8 years old. I watch t.v. all the time and all I see is the War in Iraq. Since I'm taking in all this, I want to go get a gun and start shooting all the Arabs in the United States. Now wait, Our government is the one that allowed me to be influenced by all the media in Iraq. So our government needs to be fined $25.00 for this and since they are adults allowing this they should be imprisoned also.
I forgot I was talking about our government, where everything that they do is not wrong. (LIKE THAT IS TRUE)!!!!!!!!!
It all comes down to the parent that wants to be an adult,and to teach the child what is right and wrong.
This is only another way for our government to get more money from us and to keep us poor and confused.
Example== It is legal for me to make a porn video business as long as I pay the government taxes on what I gross. But it is illegal for me to have a woman to go on the street and sell herself, because I'm not giving money to the government.
Example== It is legal for me to buy cigarettes and smoke them because they made tax money from the company. But it is illegal for me to smoke in public because they say it is bad for others. So they make a new law if in public smoking than you will be fined.
IT IS ALL ABOUT THE POWER AND MONEY. MAYBE IN 100 YEARS FROM NOW WITH ALL THE LAWS THAT ARE BEING MADE TODAY IN U.S.A. WE THE PEOPLE WILL HAVE A NEW SAYING (WE THE GOVERNMENT SLAVES HAVE NO RIGHTS)
OPEN YOUR EYES PEOPLE AND SPEAK OUT NOW. THESE ARE OUR FREEDOMS THAT THEY WANT FULL CONTROL OF.
MPAA(Motion Picture Association of America)'s rating system enforcement is not a law, NATO (national association of theater owners) and other associations use it voluntarilly. Why would video game ratings be any different from movie ratings. There are no laws governing the viewing of movies, as there shouldn't be. This goes the same with the video game industry.
learn your ish.
I used to be a theater manager. by the way.
its a game....its animated...BIG DEAL. Violent video games prepare minors (13+) for the real world. They get to experince violence and it also lets them release stress. Ive known some kids that werent allowed to watch PG13 or play "violent" video games, and they where pretty screwed up. If all this makes no sense then ignore me I just woke up lol
We have a lot of dumb laws here in MN, we can't even use real Fireworks.
The goverment isn't actually trying to raise your kids; it's just trying to get you to get a little more involved. I believe in freedom of speach, but as someone here said there are some people that lack the capacity to distinguis reality from fantasy; although, In my opinion most of them are just cowards that don't want to take responsabilty for their actions, and blame video games after being caught. Anyways is it really that bad that parents have to buy their kids a violent game in order for them to play it? All of you might be doing a great job raising your kids, and so you feel confortable with them playing violent games because your sure they won't go shooting up your neighbors and such, but there are people that don't give a sh*t about their own kids. These kids have probably not been taught right and wrong as well as others, so they are the ones that need this. For their sake let's bare with this.
At least bush doesnt give *** on video games
ha, i have been ordering certificate 18 games online since i was 11
All the goverment is saying is that they can't controll videogame retailers or gun distributers so they'll go to where the problems not at.AND WHILE WERE AT IT WE'LL GIVE OUT $25 FINES TO HELP WITH THE TRILLION DOLLAR BUGET DEFICIT WE'VE CREATED WITH ALL THE OTHER STUPID UNECESSARY DECISIONS WEV'E MADE.
A little word of advice stop letting guns rome so freely,stop letting drugs enter our country like they have passports' put more effort towards our youth with programs and training for there future.And stop nic picking on crap that's not responsible for the mess that's been caused by your departments own stupidity and iggnorrance
WHY WOULD HE PASS THIS LAW I LIKE JESSE VENTURA WAY BETTTTTA.
Our country ( or colonial power for me cause we are their colony ) sucks , to many restrictions and they don't change anything , I had a friend on messenger from Japan which I met him on runescape ( I got addicted to that game for 4 months ) and he tells me that he sees 7 year old kids buying a GTA game like normal and there in Japan the homicidal quote is around 40 a year , compare it to USA's 12,000 homicides a year. This shows that the problem is not the videogames but let's think what the USA has that Japan doesn't :
1. Military
2. Bad government
Those are the real problems , how they affect it's gonna take more than 50 pages to explain ( a tesis cuz it involves many undirect effects ) but it's true.
Jesse Ventura was a dumbass.
Why is anybody against this law? It's just a penalty for something that's already illegal- yet there's no punishment yet.
Oh, right, you're all 12 year olds.
I forgot.
Carry on!
if you want to buy an M game you have to have a parent with you, wich is a little annyoying but fine. Now they are trying to make it illeagel for a minor to buy it at all. I'm 16 and you think the government is a better parent than my own, than thats you messed up problem.
|
The QJ.net Network |
|
| Site | Feed |
| QJ.NET | RSS |
| Nintendo DS | RSS |
| PlayStation 3 | RSS |
| PSP Updates | RSS |
| Wii | RSS |
| Xbox 360 | RSS |
| MMORPG | RSS |
| Personal Computer Games | RSS |
| iPhone - iPod Touch | RSS |
| QJ.NET Forums | RSS |
| Most Commented | |
| (167) | |
| (145) | |
| (93) | |
| (78) | |
| (77) | |
| (66) | |
| (56) | |
| (50) | |
| (47) | |
| (41) | |
| (38) | |
| (36) | |
| (35) | |
| (34) | |
| (33) | |
| (32) | |
| (31) | |
| (27) | |
| (25) | |
| (25) | |
Apple
(3236)E3
(752)Gadgets
(3645)Games for Windows
(6768)iPhone
(667)MMORPG
(7949)Mobile
(2790)News
(871)Nintendo DS
(8585)Opinions & Analysis
(93)Photography
(453)PlayStation 3
(18456)PSP
(17398)Rumors
(169)Science
(2794)Site News
(52)Tabula Rasa
(421)Wii
(14150)World of Warcraft
(3730)Xbox 360
(18509)
Archives
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
May 2005
Minnesota Governor 
