Posted Dec 05, 2006 at 03:51AM by Ian C.
Listed in:
Wii,
PlayStation 3,
Xbox 360
Tags:
PS2,
wrestling
Ó
|
I have argued and still do that violent video games take off from where violent television stops. Violent television desensitizes children to criminal acts. Video games provide enough shooting practice on how to get it right. |
|
|
Permalink |
Email this |
Linking Blogs
| Digg It!
Bookmark / Find this article on: |
|
In Tosheena Robinson-Blair's column, over at The Daily News Journal, Robinson-Blair dishes out several reasons why those who 16 Comments
|
 |
by King Poubar (Unregistered) - 2006-12-05 |
|
 
|
» Violence in videogames does not create killers
Im 19 years old, first got my greasy mitts on doom at age 7 or 8.
Have i killed anyone?
Not yet at least, nor do i intend upon
Im 19 years old, first got my greasy mitts on doom at age 7 or 8.
Have i killed anyone?
Not yet at least, nor do i intend upon
|
by Hugh Mann (Unregistered) - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» Oh PUUURLEEEASE!
I really thought we had moved on from this debate. Throughout history, people have wrongly claimed that art drives societies trends and not the other way around.
If it was true that violent videogames make people become violent in nature, then shouldn't the mass of sports games out there have produced a generation of kids who are incredibly passionate about sports with a strong desire to succeed (i.e. to win, like they do in the games)
I really thought we had moved on from this debate. Throughout history, people have wrongly claimed that art drives societies trends and not the other way around.
If it was true that violent videogames make people become violent in nature, then shouldn't the mass of sports games out there have produced a generation of kids who are incredibly passionate about sports with a strong desire to succeed (i.e. to win, like they do in the games)
|
by hush404 - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» 2 facts
1- It takes an already compromised individual to even think about committing such crimes in the first place, with or without the "help" of the violence seen in video games.
2- Shooting in a game with dual joysticks and trigger buttons is no where's near the same experience of firing a real firearm. Plain and simple, a video game can't teach you how to handle a weapon, or prepare for it's kick back or deal with aiming it either.
1- It takes an already compromised individual to even think about committing such crimes in the first place, with or without the "help" of the violence seen in video games.
2- Shooting in a game with dual joysticks and trigger buttons is no where's near the same experience of firing a real firearm. Plain and simple, a video game can't teach you how to handle a weapon, or prepare for it's kick back or deal with aiming it either.
|
Re: King Poubar (Unregistered) - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» Fact 2, yes and no
Fact 2 is false.
As a Brit i cannot legally use real firearms, but have in my travels to the us.
Although the kick back is a HELL of alot different.
My aim is just as deadly air soft, light gun, or the real deal.
Fact 2 is false.
As a Brit i cannot legally use real firearms, but have in my travels to the us.
Although the kick back is a HELL of alot different.
My aim is just as deadly air soft, light gun, or the real deal.
|
Re: Stilgar91 (Unregistered) - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» that's right (at least the first part)
As King Poubar kindly sugested, fact 2 is indeed false.
No, you are not prepared for the kick back, neither feels the grip the same. But (there comes the cliché-stylish "but"), you should be better at handling weapons. Not only is your reaction time better than the average, also your hand-eye coördination should be a lot better.
But those things don't make you a killer, those things let you react quicker, better and more efficient in combat situations! We indeed would be better at shooting someone, but that's where fact 2 comes in.
If you got muscles you don't necesarily break someones nose every day, but it would help if someone would try to break your's.
I rest my case.
As King Poubar kindly sugested, fact 2 is indeed false.
No, you are not prepared for the kick back, neither feels the grip the same. But (there comes the cliché-stylish "but"), you should be better at handling weapons. Not only is your reaction time better than the average, also your hand-eye coördination should be a lot better.
But those things don't make you a killer, those things let you react quicker, better and more efficient in combat situations! We indeed would be better at shooting someone, but that's where fact 2 comes in.
If you got muscles you don't necesarily break someones nose every day, but it would help if someone would try to break your's.
I rest my case.
|
by ... (Unregistered) - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» ...
I have been playing games since I was very young. Now I am 17, and after playing gta vice city, gta san andreas, sonic, mario, and MANY other games, am I going to go around jumping on animals like mario, destorying machienes like sonic, killing mob bosses like in gta, or go kill some gangstas?
No. If someone had ever killed someoen it is not the games fault, but the persons own sick mind.
I have been playing games since I was very young. Now I am 17, and after playing gta vice city, gta san andreas, sonic, mario, and MANY other games, am I going to go around jumping on animals like mario, destorying machienes like sonic, killing mob bosses like in gta, or go kill some gangstas?
No. If someone had ever killed someoen it is not the games fault, but the persons own sick mind.
|
by Lestat (Unregistered) - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» BAn Everything
Why dont we.....
Ban books cuz we can learn to kill.
Ban TV cuz we can learn how to kill.
Ban Food becuase it kills us.
Ban people becuase they can hurt us.
Ban driving becuase people cant drive.
Just Ban everything that is not good for us and we would be in a frikin bubble eating paste out of a jar doing nothing with our lives.
On a positive note gaming has been known to be an outlet for frustration. People kill imaginary creatures and shoot people in games so they dont have to do that in real life. I dont know how many times my friends and I have been stressed out and played a game of Halo online or COD2 to calm us down.
Why dont we.....
Ban books cuz we can learn to kill.
Ban TV cuz we can learn how to kill.
Ban Food becuase it kills us.
Ban people becuase they can hurt us.
Ban driving becuase people cant drive.
Just Ban everything that is not good for us and we would be in a frikin bubble eating paste out of a jar doing nothing with our lives.
On a positive note gaming has been known to be an outlet for frustration. People kill imaginary creatures and shoot people in games so they dont have to do that in real life. I dont know how many times my friends and I have been stressed out and played a game of Halo online or COD2 to calm us down.
|
Re: CHUCKINGROCKSATSPACESHIPS - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» True
Good point!
Good point!
|
by Advertising - |
|
|
|
by tRn Cartman95 (Unregistered) - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» Look Up the Results for Yourself
Just because someone made a statement saying that videogames induced violence, go and look at the full report. It could be a 2% increase for all we know. And taking into acount percent error, that number is highly insignificant. We would need something around 10-20% to even begin to make this claim.
If video games cause violence, then why has the civilized world seen a general decline in crime since..well...forever?
If games caused violence, then pulling would stop it. So go ahead, try it. You will fail you mongering swine.
And like ... said, nobody from the early days of gaming go around jumping on people's heads or running around with a giant hammer. It just doesn't happen. It's about PARENTING. People these days are just too lazy to do that and will blame anything that they can when their child acts up.
Just because someone made a statement saying that videogames induced violence, go and look at the full report. It could be a 2% increase for all we know. And taking into acount percent error, that number is highly insignificant. We would need something around 10-20% to even begin to make this claim.
If video games cause violence, then why has the civilized world seen a general decline in crime since..well...forever?
If games caused violence, then pulling would stop it. So go ahead, try it. You will fail you mongering swine.
And like ... said, nobody from the early days of gaming go around jumping on people's heads or running around with a giant hammer. It just doesn't happen. It's about PARENTING. People these days are just too lazy to do that and will blame anything that they can when their child acts up.
|
by Koru-Sama (Unregistered) - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» OMFG
you've got to be kidding me, this bull***** again!!!???
People are sitting here *****ing about how violent video games are ruining our children's lives. Why don't they attack television violence as well, or *maybe* they should just STOP BUYING THEIR CHILDREN VIOLENT VIDEO GAMES!!! You don't go out and buy your kids pornography do you? Maybe that's why i don't hear anybody *****ing about that!!
I'm 20 years old, and you'd think that people more experienced and older than I am would surely understand that complaining about this issue is a pointless waste of time and is costing our states millions of dollars to deal with idiots that actually press charges against violent video games!!! But, I've been wrong before, because apparently no matter your age... you can still be a *****ing idiot.
The REAL problem is with the people complaining about violent video games, not the "violent video games" issue itself. They are unjustifiably afraid for no reason that a possible threat might exist in the form of one type (not all types, just video games) of media. These *fanatics* are wasting taxpayers hard earned money to fund these irrational cases against violent video games.. and IT'S ABSURD!!
There IS NO SPECIFIC THREAT directed in the form of violent and abusive video games. You have more of a threat in television and movies. Every single gamer has NO PROBLEM with violent video games. It's only adults (and i use this term only according to age, not mentality) who DON'T EVEN PLAY VIDEO GAMES that have issues against them. What's sad is that most of them are just sheep following a biased shepherd....
My final words will be this, "Give it up, because if you are one of the people that are complaining about violent video games corrupting our children.... SHUT UP, because you're WRONG."
you've got to be kidding me, this bull***** again!!!???
People are sitting here *****ing about how violent video games are ruining our children's lives. Why don't they attack television violence as well, or *maybe* they should just STOP BUYING THEIR CHILDREN VIOLENT VIDEO GAMES!!! You don't go out and buy your kids pornography do you? Maybe that's why i don't hear anybody *****ing about that!!
I'm 20 years old, and you'd think that people more experienced and older than I am would surely understand that complaining about this issue is a pointless waste of time and is costing our states millions of dollars to deal with idiots that actually press charges against violent video games!!! But, I've been wrong before, because apparently no matter your age... you can still be a *****ing idiot.
The REAL problem is with the people complaining about violent video games, not the "violent video games" issue itself. They are unjustifiably afraid for no reason that a possible threat might exist in the form of one type (not all types, just video games) of media. These *fanatics* are wasting taxpayers hard earned money to fund these irrational cases against violent video games.. and IT'S ABSURD!!
There IS NO SPECIFIC THREAT directed in the form of violent and abusive video games. You have more of a threat in television and movies. Every single gamer has NO PROBLEM with violent video games. It's only adults (and i use this term only according to age, not mentality) who DON'T EVEN PLAY VIDEO GAMES that have issues against them. What's sad is that most of them are just sheep following a biased shepherd....
My final words will be this, "Give it up, because if you are one of the people that are complaining about violent video games corrupting our children.... SHUT UP, because you're WRONG."
|
by joker (Unregistered) - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» Just.......
Just another angry b itch and/or skank on her period! HAHAHAHAHA. Your a retard if you think violence in video games is a factor in some one going out and killing people bla bla bla bla bla We've all heard the speach before. That pornograhpy bit was a great point koru-sama!
Just another angry b itch and/or skank on her period! HAHAHAHAHA. Your a retard if you think violence in video games is a factor in some one going out and killing people bla bla bla bla bla We've all heard the speach before. That pornograhpy bit was a great point koru-sama!
|
by TRUTH (Unregistered) - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» Fast Facts!
Fact: Video Games caused the Lincoln assassination.
Fact: Roman soldiers played many nonstop hours of games such as Grand Theft Auto, Mortal Kombat, and Doom, sometimes for days at a time.
Fact: It is now known that John Lennon's assassin was playing the game Tetris when he murdered the slain Beatle, not reading Catcher In The Rye as scholars had previously thought.
Fact: Hitler loved all of the Zelda games (especially the Link To The Past) because of their obvious neo-nazi views, but mostly because Link had blonde hair and blue eyes.
Fact: Video Games caused the Lincoln assassination.
Fact: Roman soldiers played many nonstop hours of games such as Grand Theft Auto, Mortal Kombat, and Doom, sometimes for days at a time.
Fact: It is now known that John Lennon's assassin was playing the game Tetris when he murdered the slain Beatle, not reading Catcher In The Rye as scholars had previously thought.
Fact: Hitler loved all of the Zelda games (especially the Link To The Past) because of their obvious neo-nazi views, but mostly because Link had blonde hair and blue eyes.
|
by Dudeman3k - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» just some thoughts
after reading articles like this and comments like yours I just have all these thoughts come to mind...
btw: I usually don't take sides and I try to see both points, but sometimes I get tired and I don't give a damn... this is one of those times
1) A lot of games train motor and cognitive skills, not just violent ones. Dance Dance Revolution is a pretty decent example. Anyone can see how it can train someone's agility and reaction time. Anyone can make a claim that DDR helps train children to run from the cops using the physical improvements resulting in hours of DDR. Is my logic flawed there? maybe a little, i don't know.
2) A lot of games for children, not just GTA, have violence in them. Sonic the Hedgehog goes around destroying property and jumping on things. Mario has been jumping on turtles for years, and has recently started punching and kicking them. Kirby shoots things from his mouth (upon other actions). Spyro the dragon is a cute little guy who breathes fire on his enemies (draw whatever you want from that).
I'm sure more people can think of similar situations.
3) Is it that violent games create violent people? Or is it that violent people are attracted to violent games? Or are the two linked by causation/correlation at all?
4) I think sports games can be worse than violent games in a way. Think about it. GTA is obvious. Most children know that violence, especially to that extent, is not something acceptable in the real world. Sports however, not just sports games, promote aggression between at least two opposing factions. You see football players ramming into each other and the audience cheering. It's a subtle promotion for aggression. (I'm just trying to use their logic).
5)Yes, violent video games can be a problem, but only when joined with uninvolved, or permissive parenting styles (maybe even authoritarian sometimes). Bad parenting is always a no no.
Don't blame the games, blame the people.
"The devil made me do it"
I had more to say, but for now I gotta go to work. I work in a clothing store where parents, along with their children, shop. I also play tons of violent video games.
FEAR ME
after reading articles like this and comments like yours I just have all these thoughts come to mind...
btw: I usually don't take sides and I try to see both points, but sometimes I get tired and I don't give a damn... this is one of those times
1) A lot of games train motor and cognitive skills, not just violent ones. Dance Dance Revolution is a pretty decent example. Anyone can see how it can train someone's agility and reaction time. Anyone can make a claim that DDR helps train children to run from the cops using the physical improvements resulting in hours of DDR. Is my logic flawed there? maybe a little, i don't know.
2) A lot of games for children, not just GTA, have violence in them. Sonic the Hedgehog goes around destroying property and jumping on things. Mario has been jumping on turtles for years, and has recently started punching and kicking them. Kirby shoots things from his mouth (upon other actions). Spyro the dragon is a cute little guy who breathes fire on his enemies (draw whatever you want from that).
I'm sure more people can think of similar situations.
3) Is it that violent games create violent people? Or is it that violent people are attracted to violent games? Or are the two linked by causation/correlation at all?
4) I think sports games can be worse than violent games in a way. Think about it. GTA is obvious. Most children know that violence, especially to that extent, is not something acceptable in the real world. Sports however, not just sports games, promote aggression between at least two opposing factions. You see football players ramming into each other and the audience cheering. It's a subtle promotion for aggression. (I'm just trying to use their logic).
5)Yes, violent video games can be a problem, but only when joined with uninvolved, or permissive parenting styles (maybe even authoritarian sometimes). Bad parenting is always a no no.
Don't blame the games, blame the people.
"The devil made me do it"
I had more to say, but for now I gotta go to work. I work in a clothing store where parents, along with their children, shop. I also play tons of violent video games.
FEAR ME
|
by A Concerned Gamer (Unregistered) - 2006-12-05 |
|
|
» Idiocy
Anyone who claims games are "training" to fire a gun correctly, either haven't held a gun, or haven't played a videogame in their lives. Holding a controller and firing the digital representation of a gun at the press of a button is worlds different from firing a gun and cannot be held as training. It's entirely ludicrous. Pointing a digitally accurate crosshair that is lined up in your point of view flawlessly by a computer is totally different from lining up those sights yourself without the assistance of a digital crosshair. It's enfuriating to hear that people attack violent videogames by claiming that they are training in any way.
Anyone who claims games are "training" to fire a gun correctly, either haven't held a gun, or haven't played a videogame in their lives. Holding a controller and firing the digital representation of a gun at the press of a button is worlds different from firing a gun and cannot be held as training. It's entirely ludicrous. Pointing a digitally accurate crosshair that is lined up in your point of view flawlessly by a computer is totally different from lining up those sights yourself without the assistance of a digital crosshair. It's enfuriating to hear that people attack violent videogames by claiming that they are training in any way.
|
by Ur mom (Unregistered) - 2006-12-06 |
|
|
» Milf hunter
these people that make these freakin debates have probably never even played video games, the opinoins are worthless
these people that make these freakin debates have probably never even played video games, the opinoins are worthless
|
by your (Unregistered) - 2006-12-06 |
|
|
» gay
nigers
nigers
Featured Content
QJ.NET Blog Network  |
|
| MyQJ | Feed / PDA |
| MyQJ | RSS / PDA |
| Blog of Blogs | Feed / PDA |
| QJ.NET | RSS / PDA |
| Gaming Consoles | Feed / PDA |
| Nintendo DS | RSS / PDA |
| PlayStation 3 | RSS / PDA |
| PSP Updates | RSS / PDA |
| Wii | RSS / PDA |
| Xbox 360 | RSS / PDA |
| PC Gaming | Feed / PDA |
| Age of Conan | RSS / PDA |
| Games for Windows | RSS / PDA |
| MMORPG | RSS / PDA |
| Tabula Rasa | RSS / PDA |
| World of Warcraft | RSS / PDA |
| Science | Feed / PDA |
| Science | RSS / PDA |
| Technology | Feed / PDA |
| Apple | RSS / PDA |
| Gadgets | RSS / PDA |
| iPhone | RSS / PDA |
| Mobile | RSS / PDA |
| Photography | RSS / PDA |
| Tech | RSS / PDA |
Add QJ.NET
User Favorites - October
| Most Commented | |
| (81) | |
| (76) | |
| (47) | |
| (45) | |
| (40) | |
| (40) | |
| (34) | |
| (31) | |
| (30) | |
| (29) | |
| (28) | |
| (27) | |
| (26) | |
| (23) | |
| (23) | |
| (22) | |
| (21) | |
| (21) | |
| (21) | |
| (21) | |
User Favorites - October
Apple
(3235)E3
(651)Gadgets
(3643)Games for Windows
(6004)iPhone
(40)MMORPG
(7713)Mobile
(2788)News
(852)Nintendo DS
(7232)Opinions & Analysis
(78)Photography
(446)PlayStation 3
(13817)PSP
(13892)Rumors
(168)Science
(2795)Site News
(46)Tabula Rasa
(420)Wii
(11949)World of Warcraft
(3700)Xbox 360
(15256)
Archives
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
May 2005
